ATHENIAN MERCANTILISM: A NEW APPROACH TO THE ATHENIAN COINAGE DECREE AND THE LAW OF NICOPHON
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14795/j.v6i3.436Keywords:
Greek Numismatics, Greek Epigraphy, Coinage Decree, Law of Nicophon, AthensAbstract
Two fragmentary specimens of Greek epigraphy, both inscribed within a century of one another (ca. 450 and 375 B.C.)[1] and both, in one manner or another, dealing with regulations of Athenian coinage, have been the source of scholarly debate and controversy. The fifth century Athenian decree (ψήφισμα) on coins, weights, and standards,[2] has been referred to as one of “the most controversial texts in the history of Greek epigraphy.”[3] The central debate surrounds its date, which then informs understanding of the nature of the decree and the motive behind its issuance. The fourth century Athenian law (νόμος) on approvers of silver coinage[4] likewise is subject to much debate regarding its textual reconstruction.
Both the fifth century decree and the fourth century law aim to control elements of monetary exchange through by eliminating the utilization, and later even the existence, of non-Athenian coinage. The differences from this perspective appear to be quantitative not qualitative—macro-managing and micro-managing monetary exchange. Notwithstanding, scholarship isolates the inscriptions and rarely considers any connection.[5]
I aim to provide a better understanding of these two inscriptions and to explore the matter of continuity between these two pieces of Athenian legislation. Along with the matter of continuity, a series of related questions are treated here. (1) Was the Coinage Decree[6] a product of nascent Athenian imperialism, as scholarly consensus maintains, or rather a means to catalyze Athenian revenue via seigniorage? (2) How successful were the Coinage Decree and the Law on Coinage? (3) What does the numismatic evidence suggest regarding successful implementation of them? Namely, do coin finds signify the regularization of anti-counterfeiting measures? (4) Is there any perceivable quantitative reduction of non-Athenian silver coinage following the Decree or Law?
[1] All dates are B.C. unless noted otherwise.
[2] ATL ii. D14 = MEIGGS/LEWIS #45.
[3] HADJI 2005, 263.
[4] SEG 26.72 = RHODES/OSBORNE #25.
[5] E.g., Mattingly not only excludes it from discussion, but makes a point to stress that he will not discuss the Coinage Law whatsoever in his work, stating: “I shall say nothing of the astonishing new document from 375/374” (1996, 403).
[6] I use the term “Coinage Decree” (from Münzgesetz), as opposed to the seldom used “Standards Decree” found in CHAMBERS, et al. (1990).
Downloads
References
ALESSANDRI 1984
Alessandri, S., ‘Il Significato Storico della Legge di Nicofonte sul Dokimastes Monetario.’ Annali della Scuola Normale Superiore de Pisa. Classe di Lettere e Filosofia 3rd ser. 14, 369–393.
AUSTIN/VIDAL-NAQUET 1977
Austin, M. and P. Vidal-Naquet., Economic and Social History of Ancient Greece. (Berkeley - University of California Press).
BARRON 1964
Barron, J., ‘Religious Propaganda of the Delian League.’ JHS 84, 35–48.
BAUMEISTER 1855
Baumeister, A., Bericht über die Verhandlungen der Königl. Preuss. Akad. Der Wissenschaften. (Berlin - Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin), 186–199.
BOGAERT 1976
Bogaert, R., ‘L’essai des monnaies dans l’antiquité.’ RBN, 191–195.
BUTTREY 1979
Buttrey T., ‘The Athenian Currency Law of 375/4 B.C.’ In: Mørkholm, O. and M. Waggoner (edd.), Greek Numismatics and Archaeology: Essays in Honor of Margaret Thompson. (Belgium - Cultura Press), 33-45.
BURY/MEIGGS 1975
Bury, J. and R. Meiggs (rev.)., A History of Greece to the Death of Alexander the Great. (New York -Routledge).
CARCHEDI 2001
Carchedi, G., For Another Europe: A Class Analysis of European Economic Integration. (New York - Verso).
CAVAIGNAC 1953
Cavaignac, E., ‘Le décret dit de Kléarkhos.’ RN5 15, 1–7.
CHAMBERS 1992/1993
Chambers, M., ‘Photographic Enhancement and a Greek Inscription.’ CJ 88, 25–31.
CHAMBERS 1994
Chambers, M., ‘The Archon’s Name in the Athens-Egesta Alliance (IG I3 11).’ ZPE 98, 171–174.
CHAMBERS 1995
Chambers, M., ‘Reading Illegible Inscriptions: Athens and Egesta.’ Thetis: Mannheimer Beiträge zur klassischen Archäologie und Geschichte Griechenlands und Zyperns 1, 49–52, pl. 5.
CHAMBERS/GALLUCCI/SPANOS 1990
Chambers, M., Gallucci, R., and P. Spanos., ‘Athens’ Alliance with Egesta in the Year of Antiphon.’ ZPE 83, 38–57.
CHARLESWORTH 1937
Charlesworth, M., ‘Flaviana.’ JRS 27, 54-62.
CRAWFORD 1968
Crawford, M., ‘Plated Coins, False Coins.’ NC, 55–59.
DESANCTIS 1937
DeSanctis, G., Review of: A. Gomme. The Population of Athens in the Fifth and Fourth Centuries B.C. In: RFIC 65, 288–309.
ENGEN 2005
Engen, D., ‘Ancient Greekbacks: Athenian Owls, the Law of Nicophon, and the Greek Economy.’ Historia 54, 359–381.
ERXLEBEN 1969/1970/1971
Erxleben, E., ‘Das Münzgesetz des DelischAttischen Seebundes.’ Arch. f. Papyrusforschung 19, 91–139; 20: 66–132; 21: 145–162.
FERRILL 1965
Ferrill. A., ‘Otho, Vitellius, and the Propaganda of Vespasian.’ CJ 60, 267-269.
FIGUEIRA 1998
Figueira, T., The Power of Money: Coinage and Politics in the Athenian Empire. (Philadelphia - University of Pennsylvania Press.
FINLEY 1965
Finley, M., ‘Classical Greece.’ In: P Lévêque (ed.), Deuxième Conférence international d’histoire économique: Aix-en-Provence. (Paris – Mouton).
FINLEY 1978
Finley, M., “The Fifth-Century Athenian Empire: A Balance Sheet.” In: Garnsey, P. and C. Whittaker (edd.), Imperialism in the Ancient World: The Cambridge University Research Seminar in Ancient History. (Cambridge - Cambridge University Press), 103-126.
FINLEY 1999
Finley, M., The Ancient Economy. (Berkeley - University of California Press).
GARDNER 1913
Gardner, P., ‘Coinage of the Athenian Empire.’ JHS 33, 147–88.
GARLAND 2001
Garland, R., The Piraeus. (London – Bristol).
GIOVANNI 1975
Giovanni, A., ‘Athenian Currency in the Late Fifth and Early Fourth Century B.C. GRBS 16, 185–195.
HADJI/KONTES 2005
Hadji, A. and Z. Kontes., ‘The Athenian Coinage Decree: Inscriptions, Coins and Athenian Politics.’ In: C. Alfaro, C. Marcos, and P. Otero (edd.), Actas del XIII Congresso Internacional de Numismática, Madrid 2003 1. (Madrid - Museos Estatales), 263–267.
HANSEN 1999
Hansen, M., The Athenian democracy in the age of Demosthenes: Structure, Principles and Ideology. (Norman - University of Oklahoma Press).
HARRIS 1991
Harris, D., ‘Gold and Silver on the Athenian Acropolis: Thucydides 2.13.4 and the Inventory Lists.’ Horos 8, 75-82.
HATZOPOULOS 2017
Hatzopoulos, M., ‘The Athenian Standards Decree: The Aphytis Fragments.’ Tekmeria 12, 235–269.
HEDRICK 1999
Hedrick, C., ‘Democracy and the Athenian Epigraphic Habit.’ Hesperia 68, 387–439.
HEDRICK 2000
Hedrick, C., ‘Epigraphic Writing and the Democratic Restoration of 307.’ In: P. Flensted-Jensen, et al. (edd.), Polis and Politics. (Copenhagen - Museum Tusculanum Press), 327–35.
HENRY 1978
Henry, A., ‘The Dating of Fifth-Century Attic Inscriptions.’ CSCA 11, 75–108.
HOWGEGO 1995
Howgego, C., Ancient History from Coins. (New York – Routledge).
JOHNSON 2012
Johnson, S., ‘Prepared Statement Regarding Counterfeiting.’ In: M. Oxley (ed.), Coin and Currency Issues Facing Congress: Can We Still Afford Money? Hearing before the Subcommittee on Domestic and International Monetary Policy, Trade, and Technology of the Committee of Financial Services U.S. House of Representatives, 109th Congress, 2nd Session. July 19, 2006. (Washington D.C. – U.S. Government Printing Office), 80-85.
JOHNSTON 2007
Johnston, A., Greek Imperial Denominations, ca. 200–275: A Study of the Roman Provincial Bronze Coinages of Asia Minor. (London - Royal Numismatic Society).
JOHNSTONE 2011
Johnstone, S., A History of Trust in Ancient Greece. (Chicago - University of Chicago Press).
JONES 1997
Jones, J., ‘Coins as Weights in the Temple Records of Didyma.’ In: K. Sheedy et al. (edd.), Numismatic Archaeology: Archaeological Numismatics. (Oxford – Oxbow), 57–69.
KAGAN 1969
Kagan, D., The Outbreak of the Peloponnesian War. (Ithaca - Cornell University Press).
KAGAN 1994
Kagan, J., An Archaic Greek Coin Hoard from the Eastern Mediterranean and Early Cypriot Coinage. (London - Taylor & Walton).
KALLET 2001
Kallet, L., Money and the Corrosion of Power in Thucydides. (Berkeley - University of California Press).
KRAAY 1976
Kraay, C., Archaic and Classical Greek Coins. (Ann Arbor - University of Michigan Press).
KRAGELUND 1998
Kragelund, P., ‘Galba’s ‘Pietas,’ Nero's victims and the Mausoleum of Augustus.’ Historia 47, 152-173.
KYRIAZIS 2009
Kyriazis, N., ‘Financing the Athenian state: Public choice in the age of Demosthenes.’ European Journal of Law and Economics 27, 109–127.
KROLL 1988
Kroll, J., ‘Silver in Solon’s Laws.’ In: R. Ashton et al. (edd.), Studies in Greek Numismatics in Memory of Martin Jessop Price. (London – Spink), 225–232.
LE RIDER 1989
Le Rider, G. (ed.)., ‘À propos d’un passage des Poroi de Xenophon.’ In: C. Kraay, O. Mørkholm, and G. Le Rider (edd.), Kraay-Mørkholm Essays: Numismatic Studies in Memory of C.M. Kraay and O. Mørkholm. (Louvain-la-Neuve - Institut supérieur d’archéologie et d’histoire de l’art, séminaire de numismatique Marcel Hoc), 159-172.
LEVICK 1982
Levick, B., ‘Propaganda and the Imperial Coinage.’ Antichthon 16, 104–116.
LEWIS 1987
Lewis, D., ‘The Athenian Coinage Decree.’ In: I. Carradice (ed.), Coinage and Administration in the Athenian and Persian Empires: The Ninth Oxford Symposium on Coinage and Monetary History. (Oxford – Oxford University Press), 53–63.
LEWIS 2002
Lewis, D., Selected Papers in Greek and Near Eastern History. (Cambridge - Cambridge University Press).
LOW 2008
Low, P., The Athenian Empire. (Edinburgh - Edinburgh University Press).
MARTIN 1985
Martin, T., Sovereignty and Coinage in Classical Greece. (Princeton - Princeton University Press).
MATTINGLY 1961
Mattingly, H., ‘The Athenian Coinage Decree.’ Historia 10, 148–188.
MATTINGLY
Mattingly, H., ‘The Athenian Coinage Decree and the Assertion of Empire.’ In I. Carradice (ed.), Coinage and Administration in the Athenian and Persian Empires: The Ninth Oxford Symposium on Coinage and Monetary History. (Oxford – Oxford University Press), 65–71.
MATTINGLY
Mattingly, H., The Athenian Empire Restored: Epigraphic and Historical Studies. (Ann Arbor - University of Michigan Press).
MCCANN 1968
McCann, A., ‘The Portraits of Septimius Severus.’ MAAR 30, 4-222.
MEIGGS/LEWIS 1988
Meiggs, R and D. Lewis., A Selection of Greek Historical Inscriptions to the End of the Fifth Century B.C. (Oxford - Oxford University Press).
MERITT 1963
Meritt, B., ‘The Dating of Documents to the Mid-Fifth Century—I.’ JHS 82, 67–74.
MERITT 1975
Meritt, B., ‘Perikles, the Athenian Mint, and the Hephaisteion.’ PAPS 119, 267–274.
METCALF 1993
Metcalf, W., ‘Whose Liberalitas? Propaganda and Audience in the Early Roman Empire.’ Rivista Italiana di Numismatica e Science Affini 95, 337-346.
MØRKHOLM 1982
Mørkholm, O., ‘Some Reflection on the Production and Use of Coinage in Ancient Greece.’ Historia 31.3, 290–305.
OBER 2008
Ober, J., Democracy and Knowledge: Innovation and Learning in Classical Athens. (Princeton - Princeton University Press).
OBER 2015
Ober, J., ‘Access, Fairness, and Transaction Costs: Nikophon's Law on Silver Coinage (Athens 375/4 BCE).’ In: D. Kehoe, D. Ratzan, and U. Yiftech (edd.), Law and Transaction Costs in the Ancient Economy. (Ann Arbor University of Michigan Press).
PAUL/IERARDI 2002
Paul, G. and M. Ierardi. (edd.)., Roman Coins and Public Life under the Empire: E. Togo Salmon Papers II. (Ann Arbor - University of Michigan Press).
RHODES/OSBORNE 2003
Rhodes, P. and R. Osborne., Greek Historical Inscriptions: 404–323 BC. (Oxford – Oxford University Press)
RICHARDSON 2000
Richardson, M., ‘The Location of Inscribed Laws in Fourth-Century Athens. IG II2 244, on Rebuilding the Walls of Piraeus (337/6 BC),’ In: P. Flensted-Jensen, et al. (edd.), Polis and Politics. (Copenhagen - Museum Tusculanum Press), 601–615.
ROBINSON 1935
Robinson, D., ‘A New Fragment of the Athenian Decree on Coinage.’ AJP 56, 149–154.
ROBINSON 1949
Robinson, D., ‘The Athenian Coinage Decree and the Coinages of the Allies.” In Commemorative Studies in Honor of Theodore Leslie Shear, Hesperia Suppl. 8, 324–340.
ROBINSON 1960
Robinson, E., Some Problems in the Later Fifth Century Coinage of Athens, ANSMN 9. (New York – American Numismatic Society), 1-15.
ROMSTEDT 1914
Romstedt, M., Die wirtschaftliche Organization des athenischen Reiches. (Leipzig - Druck von Thomas & Hubert.
ROWLAND 1966
Rowland, R., ‘Numismatic Propaganda under Cinna.’ TAPA 97, 407-19.
SCHULLER 1974
Schuller, W., Die Herrschaft der Athener im ersten attischen Seebund. (Berlin - de Gruyter).
SMARZCZ/TIETZEL 2001
Smarzcz, R., and M. Tietzel., ‘Verfahren zur Zuteilung von Mobilfunklizenzen.’ List Forum 27, 316–334.
STROUD 1974
Stroud, R., ‘An Athenian Law on Silver Coinage.’ Hesperia 43.2, 157–188.
SUTHERLAND 1943
Sutherland, C., Corn and Coin: A Note on Greek Commercial Monopolies.’ AJP 64, 129–147.
THOMPSON/MØRKHOLM/KRAAY 1973
Thompson, M., O. Mørkholm, and C. Kraay (edd.)., An Inventory of Greek Coin Hoards. (New York - American Numismatic Society).
THOMPSON 1970
Thompson, W., ‘The Golden Nikai and the Coinage of Athens.’ NC 7.10, 1-6.
VAN ALFEN 2005
Van Alfen, P., ‘Problems in Ancient Imitative and Counterfeit Coinage.’ In: Z. Archibald, et al. (edd.), Making, Moving, and Managing: The New World of Ancient Economics, 323–31 B.C. (Oxford: Oxbow), 322–354.
VON GAERTRINGEN/KLAFFEBACH 1923
Hiller von Gaertringen, F. and Klaffebach, G., ‘Das Münzgesestz des ersten athenischen Seebundes.’ ZFN 35, 217–221.
WADE-GREY 1931
Wade-Grey, H., The Financial Decrees of Kallias (I.G. I2, 91–92).’ JHS 51, 57–85.
WEIL 1906
Weil, R., ‘Das Münzmonopol Athens im ersten attischen Seebund.’ ZFN 25, 52–62.
WEIL 1910
Weil, R., ‘Das Münzrecht der ΞΥΜΜΑΧΟΙ im ersten attischen Seebund.’ ZFN 28, 351–364.
WILAMOWITZ-MOELLENDORF 1880
Wilamowitz-Moellendorf, U., Aus Kydathen. (Berlin - Weidmannsche Buchhandlung).
ZANKER 1990
Zanker, P., The Power of Images in the Age of Augustus. (Ann Arbor - University of Michigan Press).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal, we use CC BY-NC-ND license (Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs) wich only allowing others to download your works and share them with others as long as they credit you, but they can’t change them in any way or use them commercially.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
