GORGONEION AND GORGON-MEDUSA: A CRITICAL RESEARCH REVIEW
Abstract
Our paper aims at a critical reviewing of the research that has dealt with the Gorgon-Medusa and Gorgoneion (decapitated head) apotropaic feminine beast, as recorded in various artifacts and monuments of the ancient Greek World, from early 19th century until today. Multiple works by ancient sources provide a wide-ranging and diverse picture of the fabled creature and her fateful encounter with the Greek hero Perseus. The use of ancient written historical sources is particularly emphasized and eastern influences on texts and iconography is discussed. As a natural consequence of the interactions, the association of Gorgons with other deities and the Potnia theron (Mistress of Animals) has been variously assessed by scholars with predominant its apotropaic property. Medusa appears in a variety of mythological stories and is depicted in a variety of ways in ancient art. The source of the artistic creation in painting and sculpture is founded on the legends and myths from the remote past, with a sudden appearance and apex in the Greek Archaic period. The review covers the period from prehistory to Late antiquity, whereas, the earliest form of a scarecrow is transformed to the known image of Gorgon/Medusa, and eventually from an ugly to beautiful, a metamorphosis which has been attaching various interpretations. The uniqueness of this “beast” form has emerged through its multifaced representations and mythological reports in the known ancient Greek World of the southeastern Mediterranean and its neighbor areas. Gorgon/Medusa-Gorgoneion in art as witnessed in archaeological remains has been shown to persist in all everyday activities of the ancient World and has been subjected to wide social, cultural, ideological considerations.
Keywords
DOI: 10.14795/j.v9i1.741
References
AURÉGAN/PALAYRET 1995
Aurégan, P./Palayret, P., Dix étapes de la pensée occidentale - Des présocratiques à la modernité (Paris: Ellipses).
BAUMBACH 2011
Baumbach, S., Medusa’s gaze and the aesthetics of fascination, Anglia - Zeitschrift für englische Philologie 128/2, 225–245.
BELSON 1967
BENSON, J.L., The central group of the Corfu pediment. In: Rohde-Liegle, M. (ed.), Gestalt und Geschichte-Festschrift Karl Schefold, zu seinem sechzigsten Geburtstag, 26. Januar 1965 (Bern: Francke), 48-60.
BELSON 1980
Belson, J.D., The Medusa Rondanini: A New Look, American Journal of Archaeology 84, 373-378.
BLIKENBERG 1924
Blikenberg, C., Gorgonne et Lionne, Revue Archéologique 19, 267-277.
BOYLE 2000
Boyle, N., Goethe: The Poet and the Age, vol. II (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
BREMMER 1996
Bremmer, J.N., Gorgo/Medusa, Oxford Classical Dictionary (OCD) 3, 643.
BUSCHOR 1958
Buschor, E., Medusa Rondanini (Stuttgart:W. Kohlhammer).
COOK 1914-40
Cook, A., Zeus, vol. 3.1 (Cambridge: University Press).
COOPER 2007
Cooper, C.L., Winged figures in Corinthian vase-painting: a contextual approach to the use of iconography on Corinthian pottery in the Greek world. PhD thesis, King’s College London.
CROON 1955
Croon, J. H., The Mask of the Underworld Daemon, Journal of Hellenic Studies 75, 9-16.
DEXTER 2010
Dexter, M.R., Τhe ferocious and the erotic. Beautiful Medusa and the Neolithic Bird and Snake, Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion 26/1, 25–41
ΕRSCH/GRUEBER 1862
Εrsch, J.S./Grueber, J.G., Allgemeine Encyclopädie der Wissenschaften und Künste 74, 397-398, 401-403.
ESPERANDIEU 1966
Esperandieu, E., Recueil général des bas-reliefs, statues et bustes de la Gaule romaine. Vol.15, Gaule germanique, Suppléments (suite) (Bas-reliefs Gaule 58 av. J.-C.-511 Sculpture gallo-romaine, 1907-1938), by R. Lantier (1947-1966) (Paris: Presses Universitaires de France).
FLOREN 1977
Floren, J., Studien zur Typologie des gorgoneion (Munster Westfallen: Aschendorff Verlag).
FRITZILAS 2010
Fritzilas, S., Chthonian Gorgon: the myth in Greek ceramics (Tripolis: Fylla Press) (in Greek).
FROTHINGHAM 1911
Frothingham, A.L., Medusa, Apollo, and the Great Mother, American Journal of Archaeology 15/3, 349-377.
FROTHINGHAM 1915
Frothingham, Α.L., Medusa II. The Vegetation Gorgoneion, American Journal of Archeology 19/1, 13–23.
FURTWÄNGLER 1885
Furtwängler, A., Beschreibung der Vasensammlung im Antiquarium (Berlin: W. Spemann).
FURTWÄNGLER 1886-1890
Furtwängler, A., Gorgones und Gorgo. In: Roscher, W.H. (ed.), Ausfahrliches Lexikon der griechischen und romischen Mythologie. 1.2 (Leipzig: Teubner).
FURTWÄNGLER 1893
Furtwängler, A., Meisterwerke der griechischen Plastik (Leipzig: Giesecke und Devrient), 325-332.
FURTWÄNGLER 1894
Furtwängler, A., Gorgones und Gorgo. In: Roscher, W.H. (ed.), Ausführliches Lexikon der Griechischen und Römischen Mythologie. 1.2 (Leipzig: Teubner).
GARBER/VICKERS 2003
Garber, M./Vickers, J.N. (eds.), The Medusa Reader (New York-London: Routledge).
GEROGIANNIS1927-1928
Gerogiannis, Κ., Gorgo or Medusa, Archaeologiki Ephimeris, 128-176.
GIMBUTAS 2001
Gimbutas, M., The Living Goddesses, edited and supplemented by Miriam Robbins Dexter (Oakland, CA: University of California Press Ltd).
GOLDMAN 1961
Goldman, B., The Asiatic Ancestry of the Greek Gorgon, Berytus 14, 1-23.
HOWE 1954
Howe, T.P., The Origin and Function of the Gorgon-Head, American Journal of Archaeology 58/3, 209-221.
JAMESON 1990
Jameson, M.H., Perseus, the Hero of Mycenae. In: Hägg, R./Nordquist, G.C. (eds), Celebrations of Death and Divinity in the Bronze Age Argolid. Proceedings of the Sixth International Symposium at the Swedish Institute at Athens, 11-13 June 1988 (Stockholm: P. Åström), 213-223.
KARAGIORGA 1970
Karagiorga, T., Gorgieii head, Orign and meaning of gorgonean images in the worship during the archaic period, Monograph, PhD, University of Athens, Bibliothek of Athens Archaeological Society, No. 69 (in Greek).
KARAGLOU 2018
Karaglou, K., Dangerous Beauty: Medusa in Classical Art, The Metropolitan Museum of Art Bulletin 75/3.
KRAUSKOPF/DAHLINGER 1988
Krauskopf, Ι./Dahlinger, S.C., Gorgo, Gorgones, LIMC IV, 319-330.
LAZAROU 2019
Lazarou, A., Prehistoric Gorgoneia: a Critical Reassessment, Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica, 25/2, 353–385.
LAZAROU 2021
Lazarou, A., Diachronical study of Gorgo/Medusa in the Helladic World till Late Antiquity, PhD thesis, University of Peloponnese, Dept. of History, Archaeology and Cultural Resources Management, Kalamata, Greece (in Greek, unpublished).
LEVEZOW 1832
Levezow, K., Über die Entwicklung des Gorgonen-Ideals in der Poesie und bildenden Kunst der Alten (Berlin: Druckerei der Königlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften).
ΜARINATOS 1927-1928
Marinatos, S., Gorgones and Gorgoneia, Archaeologiki Ephimeris 66-67, 7-41 (in Greek).
MILOVANOVIC/ ANDELKOVIC GRASAR 2017
Milanovic, B./Andelkovic Grasar, J., Female power that protects: examples of the apotropaic and decorative functions of the medusa in roman visual culture from the territory of the central Balkans, Starinar 67, 167-182.
NILSSON 2020
Nilsson, M.P., The Mycenaean Origin of Greek Mythology (Berkeley: University of California Press).
OGDEN 2008
Ogden, D., Perseus (London: Routledge).
PAYNE 1931
Payne, H., Necrocorinthia: a study of Corinthian art in the Archaic period (Oxford: Clarendon Press).
PETTAZZONI 1921
Pettazzoni, R., Le origini della testa di Medusa, Bolletino D’Arte 2/1, 491-510.
PHINNEY 1971
Phinney, Ε., Perseus’ battle with the gorgons, Transactions and Proceedings of the American Philological Association, 102, 445-463.
ROBERTSON 1958
Robertson, M., 1958, The Gorgos Cup, American Journal of Archaeology 62, 55-66.
ROBERTSON 1975
Robertson, M., A history of Greek art, 2 vols. (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
ROBBINS 1940
Robbins, F.E. (ed.)., Ptolemy: Tetrabiblos [Loeb Classical Library IV.9] (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press).
ROSCHER 1896
Roscher, W.H., Kynanthropie handelnde Fragment des Marcellus von Side (Leipzig: S. Hirzel).
ROSE 1928
Rose, H., Handbook of Greek mythology (London: Methuen & Co).
ROUARD 2022
Rouard, X., Did Indo-European languages stem from a Trans-Eurasian original language? an interdisciplinary approach, Scientific Culture 8/1, 15-49. DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.5717164.
SCHEFOLD 1934
Schefold, K., Untersuchungen zu den Kertscher Vasen (Leipzig: Walter de Gruyter).
SCHEFOLD/JUNG 1988
Schefold, K./Jung, F., Urkönige (Munich: Max Hirmer).
SERFONTEIN 1991
Serfontein, S.M., Medusa: From Beast to Beauty in Archaic and Classical Illustration from Greece and South Italy, Master of Arts, Hunter College of the City University of New York, 108 p.
TESTER 1987
Tester, J., A history of western astrology (New Hampshire: Boydell and Brewer).
THEMELIS 1994
Themelis, P., Hellenistic Architectural Terracottas from Messene. In: Winter, N.A. (ed.), Proceedings of the International Conference on Greek Architectural Terracottas of the Classical and Hellenistic Periods, December 12-15, 1991 [Hesperia Supplements 27], 141-169, 390-398.
THEMELIS 2017
Themelis, P., Περσέας και Μέδουσα. In: Themelis, P./Spathi, M./Psaroudakis, K. (eds.), Ιερά και Λατρείες της Μεσσήνης. Από τα αρχαίαστα βυζαντινά χρόνια. Πρακτικα ∆ιεθνουσ Αρχαιολογικου Συνεδριου (Αθηνα 25 οκτωβριου 2014) [Sanctuaries and cults of Messene. From the pre-classical to the byzantine period. Proceedings of the International Archaeological Congress (Athens, 25 October 2014)] (Athens: Hetaireia Messēniakōn Archaiologikōn Spoudōn), 179-192 (in Greek).
TOPPER 2007
Topper, K., Perseus, the maiden medusa, and the imagery of abduction, Hesperia 76, 73 – 105.
ΤOPPER 2010
Topper, K., Maidens, fillies and the death of medusa on a seventh-century pithos, Journal of Hellenic Studies 130, 109−119.
TSIAFAKIS 2003
Tsiafakis, D., ΠΕΛΩΡΑ: Fabulus Creatures and/or Demons of Death? Ιn: Padgett, J.M. (ed.), Τhe Centaur’s Smile. The Human Animal in Early Greek Art (Princeton: Princeton University Art Museum), 73-99.
VERNANT 1984
Vernant, J.-P. (pref.)., La Cité des images. Religion et société en Grèce antique (Paris: Fernand Nathan).
VERNANT 1985
Vernant, J.P., La mort dans les yeux (Paris: Hachette).
WEIZSICKER 1909
Weizsicker, P., Phobos, In: Roscher, W.H., Ausführliches Lexikon der griechischen und römischen Mythologie 3.2 (Leipzig: Teubner), 2393ff.
WILK 2000
Wilk, S.R., Medusa: Solving the Mystery of the Gorgon (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
WOLTER 1909
Wolter, S.K.P., Ein Apotropaion aus Baden, Bonner Jahrbücher 118, 270ff.
WUNDT 1919
Wundt, W., Völkerpsychologie (Leipzig: A. Kröner).
ZELL 1911
Zell, Α., Riesen der Tierwelt (Berlin/Wien: Ullstein Verlag).
ZOLOTNIKOVA 2016
Zolotnikova, O.A., 2016, A hideous monster or a beautiful maiden? Did the Western Greeks alter the concept of Gorgon? In: Reid, H.L./Tanasi, D. (eds.), Philosopher Kings and Tragic Heroes. Essays on Images and Ideas from Western Greece (Sioux, Iowa: Parnassos Press), 353-370.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
ISSN: 2360-266X