THE METROLOGICAL SYSTEMS OF THE FINAL BRONZE AGE BALANCE WEIGHTS AND THE PRE-ROMAN COINAGE OF ATLANTIC IBERIA: A SHARED SYRIAN STANDARD?

Eleftheria Pappa

Abstract


The study departs from recent suggestions that locally produced balance weights from settlement sites in central Portugal, dated to the Final Bronze Age (1200-900) are based on a Late Bronze Age Syrian/Ugaritic metrological system (13th-12thc. BCE). These proposals have been based on the comparative studies of the weights of these Atlantic objects, but have not been examined rigorously in comparison with Near Eastern metrological systems, despite the claims they make. This has repercussions for the conclusions drawn so far. 

            The present study has a threefold aim. First, it examines this hypothesis of a Syrian derivation of metrological systems underlying the local production of balance weights in Atlantic Iberian settlements (ca. 1200-900 BCE). Secondly, it investigates whether these local balance weights bear any metrological relationship to those balance weights of Phoenician typologies encounterd in Atlantic Iberian sites of the colonial period (8th-6th c. BCE). Thirdly, taking as a case study the better documented evidence from Alcácer do Sal, it examines for the first time whether these metrological systems, in use for centuries in Atlantic Iberia, underly the metrologies of the earliest, pre-Roman, locally-minted coinage, which follows Phoenician iconography but is struck using the syllabary of the indigenous languages, developed in the 8thc. BCE as an adaptation of the Phoenician script. The study suggests that the dating of the earliest group of balance weights needs to be lowered.  In addition, it documents a likely derivation of the metrological system of coinage from the Phoenician milieuof Iberia, rather than the 3rdc. BCE Carthaginian metrologies, as advocated so far. This is supported by the metrological continuity between balance weights and coinage,  and the latter's iconography, as the present study documents.

 


Full Text: PDF

DOI: 10.14795/j.v6i1.367

References

Alexandropoulos, J., Les monnaies de l'Afrique Antique: 400 av. J.-C.-40 ap. J.-C. (Toulouse: Presses Universitaires du Mirail).

Almagro-Grobea, M., Cyprus, Phoenicia and Iberia: From ‘precolonisation’ to colonisation in the ‘Far West’. In: Bonfante, L. and Karageorghis, V. (eds.), Italy and Cyprus in Antiquity: 1500–450 BC (Nicosia: Department of Antiquities), 239–270.

Álvarez Martí-Aguilar, M. / Ferrer Albelda, E., Identidad y identidades entre los fenicios de la Península Ibérica en el período colonial. In: Wulff Alonso, F. ⁄ Álvarez Martí-Aguilar, M. (eds), Identidades, culturas y territórios en la Andalucía prerromana. Historia y Geografía Número 153 (Malaga 2009), 165–203.

Araújo, M. F. ⁄ de Barros, L. ⁄ Teixeira, A. C. ⁄ de Melo, A.A., EDXRF study of Prehistoric artefacts from Quinta do Almaraz (Cacilhas, Portugal). Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section B: Beams Interactions with Materials and Atoms 213: 741–746.

Arruda, A M., A Oeste Tudo de Novo: novos dados e outros modelos interpretativos para a orientalização do território português. In: Arruda, A.M. (ed.), Fenícios e Púnicos, por Terra e Mar 2. Actas do VI Congresso Internacional de Estudos Fenícios e Púnicos. Lisboa: UNIARQ, 512-535.

Barros, L. ⁄ Cardoso, J.L. ⁄ Sabrosa, A., Fenicios na margem sul do Tejo. Economia e integração cultural no povoado do Almaraz-Almada. In: Tavares, A.A. (ed.), Os Fenícios no território português, Actas do colóquio ‘Os Fenícios no território português’, estado da questão - Estudos Orientais” 4 (Lisbon: Instituto Oriental d Universidade Nova da Lisboa) 143–181.

Barros, L. ⁄ Monge Soares, A., Cronologia absoluta para a occupação orientalizante da Quinta do Almaraz, no estuário do Tejo. O Arqueólogo Português Série IV, 22, 333–352.

Brodie, N. J. ⁄ Steel, L., Cypriot Black‐On‐Red ware: towards a characterization. Archaeometry, 38: 263-278.

Callegarin, L. ⁄ Paz García-Bellido, Ma, Prólogo. Paz García-Bellido, Ma. ⁄ Callegarin, L. ⁄ Jiménez Díez, A. (eds.) Barter, money and coinage in the Ancient Mediterranean (10th-1st centuries BC), Anejos de Archivo Español de Arqueología LVIII (Madrid: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas), 7-9.

Campo, M., Mercado, dinero y moneda en el nordeste de Iberia (ss. V-III a.C.). Paz García-Bellido, Ma. ⁄ Callegarin, L. ⁄ Jiménez Díez, A. (eds.) Barter, money and coinage in the Ancient Mediterranean (10th-1st centuries BC), Anejos de Archivo Español de Arqueología LVIII (Madrid: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas), 189-202.

Celestino Pérez, S. ⁄ López Ruiz, C., Tartessos and the Phoenicians in Iberia (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

Chic, G., La miel y las bestias, Habis 28: 153-163.

Correia, V.H., Moeda, epigrafia e identade cultural no ocidente peninsular pré-romano. In: Chaves Tristán, F. ⁄ Garcia Farnández, F.J. (eds), Moneta qua scripta. La moneda como soporte de escritura, Anejos de Arquivo Español de Arqueología XXXIII (Seville: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones científicas; Universidad de Sevilla; Fondaciçon El Monte), 267-290.

da Silva, A.C.F. ⁄ da Silva, C. T. ⁄ Lopes, A.B., Depósito de fundidor do final da Idade do Bronze do Castro da Senhora da Guia (Baiôes, S. Pedro do Sul, Viseu). Lucerna. Homenagem a D. Domingos Pinho Brandâo, 1984. Porto, 73-110.

Elayi, J. and Elayi, A.G., Recherches sur les poids phéniciens, Suppléments à Transeuphratène, 5 (Leuven: Peeters).

Eshel, T. ⁄ Yahalom-Mack, N. ⁄ Shalev, S. ⁄ Tirosh, O. ⁄ Erel, Y. ⁄ Gilboa, A., Four Iron Age Silver Hoards from Southern Phoenicia: From Bundles to Hacksilber. Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research, (379), 197-228.

Fales, F.M., Prices in Neo-Assyrian Sources, State Archives of Assyria Bulletin X, 11–53.

Ferrer Albelda, E., El poblamiento en el 1er milenio a.: Baesippo y su territorio.

In: Ferrer Albelda, E. ⁄ Cantillo Duarte, J.J. (eds), Arqueología en Vejer. De la Prehistoria al Período Andalusí (Sevilla: Universidad de Sevilla; Ayuntamiento de Vejer de la Frontera) 55-94.

García-Bellido, M. P., Hackgold and Hacksilber in protomonetary Iberia. In: Paz García-Bellido, Ma. ⁄ Callegarin, L. ⁄ Jiménez Díez, A. (eds.) Barter, money and coinage in the Ancient Mediterranean (10th-1st centuries BC), Anejos de Archivo Español de Arqueología LVIII (Madrid: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas), 121-137.

Georgiou, A., The settlement histories of Cyprus at the opening of the twelfth century BC. Cahiers du Centre d’Etudes Chypriotes 44: 109-131.

Gilboa, A. and Goren, Y. 2015. Early Iron Age Phoenician networks: an optical mineralogy study of Phoenician Brichromeand related wares in Cyprus. Ancient West & East 14:73-110. 10.2143/AWE.14.0.3108189

Gilboa, A., ⁄Sharon, I.⁄ Boaretto, E. 2008. Tel Dor and the chronology of Phoenician “pre-colonisation” stages, in Beyond the Homeland (Ancient Near Eastern Studies Supplement 28), edited by C. Sagona, 113–204. Leuven: Peeters.

Jenkins, C.K. 1983. The Mqabba (Malta) hoard of Punic bronze coins. Rivista di Studi Fenici 11, Supplemento: 19-36.

Koch, J.T., Las inscripciones del suroeste y el Tarteso de la arqueologia y de la historia. In: Campos, J.M. and J. Alvar (eds), Tarteso. El Emporio del Metal. Córdoba: Editorial Almuzara, 541-558.

Kroll, J.N., Early Iron Age balance weights at Lefkandi, Euboea. Oxford Journal of Archaeology 27(1): 37-48.

Kroll, J.H., Minting for Export: Athens, Aegina, and Others. In Faucher, T. / Marcellesi, M-C, / Picard, O. (eds), Nomisma. La circulation monétire dans le monde grec antique. BCH Supplément, Bulletin de Correspondence Hellénique, Actes du colloque international Athènes, 14-17 avril 2010 (Athens: École Française d Athènes), 27-38.

Le Rider, G. ⁄ Verdan, S., La trouvaille d’Erétrie: réserve d’un orfèvre ou dépôt monétaire? Antike Kunst 45, 141-152.

Maia, M.G.P., Fenícios em Tavira. In: M. G. P. Maia ⁄ Fernandes, C. ⁄Lopes, M. ⁄ Cavaco, S. (eds), Tavira. Território e Poder, Lisbon, 52-72.

Maia, M.G.P, Tavira, como um porto-santuário de influência fenícia, in Actas do 3o Encontro de Arqueologia do Algarve, Silves, 20, 21 e 22 de Outobro de 2005 (Xelb 6), 227-240.

Mayet, F., L’ établissement phénicien d’ Abul (Alcácer do Sal). In R. Étienne and F. Mayet (eds), Itinéraires lusitaniens, trente année de collaboration archéologique luso-française: actes de la réunion tenue à Bordeaux les 7 et 8 avril 1995 à l'occasion du 30e anniversaire de la Mission archéologique française au Portugal (Paris: De Boccard), 255-271.

Mayet, F. ⁄ da Silva, C. T., Le site phénicien d'Abul (Portugal): Comptoir et Sanctuaire (Paris: De Boccard).

Mora Serrano, B., Las fuentes de la iconografía monetal fenicio-púnica. In: Paz García-Bellido, Ma. ⁄ Callegarin, L. ⁄ Jiménez Díez, A. (eds.) Barter, money and coinage in the Ancient Mediterranean (10th-1st centuries BC), Anejos de Archivo Español de Arqueología LVIII (Madrid: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas), 157-168.

Nikolopoulos, E., Σχέσεις της Ιβηρικής Χερσονήσου με την Ανατολική Μεσόγειο κατά τη 2η και στις Αρχές της 1ης Χιλιετίας π.Χ: Μυθος και Πραγματικοτητα, (Ph.D.Diss., National and Kapodistrian University of Athens).

Núñez, F.J., The ceramic repertoire of the Iron Age. In Aubet, M.E., Núñez, F.J., and L. Trellisó (eds), The Phoenician Cemetery of Tyre-Al Bass II. Archaeological Seasons 2002-2005, Bulletin d’archéologie et d’architecture libanaises [BAAL] Hors-Série IX (Beirut. Beirut: Ministère de la Culture, Direction Géneral des Antiquitès), 261-371.

Olaio, A., O povoado da Quinta do Almaraz (Almada, Portugal) no âmbito da ocupação no Baixo Tejo durante o 1º milénio a.n.e.: os dados do conjunto anfórico, Spal 27 (2), 125 163.

Pappa, E., Framing some aspects of the Early Iron Age ‘chronological mess’: Aegean synchronisms with the West and their significance for the Greek Geometric series, Kubaba 3, 2-38.

Pappa, E., Early Iron Age Exchange in the West: Phoenicians in the Mediterranean and the Atlantic, Ancient Near East Supplement 43, (Leuven; Paris; Walpole, MA: Peeters).

Pappa, E., Who’s the Phoenician on the Atlantic? Disentangling seafaring from colonisation in western Iberia and Morocco. In: Pedersen, R. (ed), On Sea and Ocean: New Research in Phoenician Seafaring, 23–25 June 2011, Archäologisches Seminar der Philipps Universität Marburg, Marburger Beiträge zur Archäologie 2, (Marburg: Eigenverlag des Archäologischen Seminars der Philipps-Universität Marburg), 71-94.

Pappa, E., The Phoenician Sanctuary of Palácio da Galeria in Tavira (Portugal): overview, selected contexts and their assemblages from the excavations of the Campo Arqueológico de Tavira, Cuadernos de Arqueología Mediterránea 23 (Barcelona: Edicions Bellaterra).

Pappa, E., A mere addition to someone else's genealogy? Perceptions of ancient cultural heritage, public policy, and collective memory in Portugal. In: Dakouri-Hild, A. (ed.), Special Issue: Public Archaeologies of the Ancient Mediterranean, Journal of Eastern Mediterranean Archaeology and Heirateg Studies 5 (3-4), 287-310.

Paz García-Bellido, Ma., La relación económica entre la minería y la moneda púnica.

In: Paz García-Bellido, Ma. ⁄ Callegarin, L. ⁄ Jiménez Díez, A. (eds.) Barter, money and coinage in the Ancient Mediterranean (10th-1st centuries BC), Anejos de Archivo Español de Arqueología LVIII (Madrid: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas), 127-144.

Ramón Torres, J., Las ánforas fenicio-púnicas del Mediterráneo central y occidental. (Barcelona: Publicacions Universitat de Barcelona).

Ruiz Gálvez Priego, M., Writing, counting, self-awareness, experiencing distant worlds. Identity processes and freelance trade in the Bronze Age/IronAge transition. In: Celestino Pérez, S. ⁄ Ráfels SN ⁄ Armada, X-L (eds), Contacto cultural entre el Mediterráneo y el Atlántico (siglos XII-VIII ane). La precolonización a debate (Rome: CSIC Escuela Española de Historia y Arqueología en Roma), 27-40.

Ruiz-Gálvez, M., The Atlantic Iberia. A threshold between East and West. In: Almagro, M. (ed.), Iberia. Protohistory of the Far West of Europe: from Neolithic to Roman Conquest (Burgos: Universidad de Burgos; Fundación de Burgos), 161-180.

Schreiber, N., The Cypro-Phoenician Pottery of the Iron Age, Culture and History of the Ancient near East (Leiden: Brill).

Sáez Romero, A.M., Fish processing and salted-fish trade in the Punic West: new archaeological data and historical evolution. In: Botte, E. ⁄ Leitch, V. (eds), Fish and Ships: Production et Commerce des Salsamente durant l’Antiquité, Bibliothèque d’Archéologie Méditerranéenne et Africaine 17 (Paris: Centre Camille Jullian), 159-174.

Spindler, K. ⁄ da Veiga Ferreira, O., Der spätzbronzenzeitlichen Kuppelbau von der Le Roça do Casal do Meio in Portugal, Madrider Mitteilungen 14, 60–108.

Torres Ortiz, M., ¿Una colonización tartésica en el interfluvio Tajo-Sado durante la Primera Edad? Revista Portuguesa de Arqueología 8, 193-213.

Tschegg, C. ⁄ Ntaflos, T. ⁄ Hein, I., Integrated geological, petrologic and geochemical approach to establish source material and technology of Late Cypriot Bronze Age Plain White ware ceramics, Journal of Archaeological Science 36 (5), 1103-1114.

Vilaça, R., Ponderais do Bronze Final-Ferro Inicial do Ocidente Peninsular: novos dados e questões em aberto. In: Paz García-Bellido, Ma. ⁄ Callegarin, L. ⁄ Jiménez Díez, A. (eds.) Barter, money and coinage in the Ancient Mediterranean (10th-1st centuries BC), Anejos de Archivo Español de Arqueología LVIII (Madrid: Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas), 139-167.

Valério, M., Reflexões sobre a origem e formação da Escrita paleo-hispânica do sudoeste e o seu Lugar na história dos sistemas de escrita, Palaeohispanica 16, 115-151.

Visoná, P. (ed), Carthaginian bronze coinage in Sardinia. In: Studie Phoenicia IX. Seminaire de numismatique marcel hoc Université catholique de Louvaine-la-Neuve, (Louvaine: Université catholique de Louvaine-la-Neuve), 122-132.

Visoná, P., Carthaginian coinage in perspective. American Journal of Numismatics, Second Series 10, 1-31.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.

ISSN: 2360-266X