TROPAEUM TRAIANI: REVISITING THE FIELD FINDINGS OF CARL WILHELM WUTZER (1856) VS. EXCAVATION DATA OF GRIGORE TOCILESCU (1885) ON THE TRIUMPHAL MONUMENT
Abstract
Abstract
The Triumphal Monument Tropaeum Traiani of Adamclisi, Romania is analyzed with reference to the survey published by the German Professor Carl Wilhelm Wutzer after his trip of 1856 in Dobrudja. Since 1882, Tocilescu excavated the ruin and appreciated past data, although there was enough criticism about the idea of considering the monument as built by Persians and geometrical figures of parapets as Persian letters. Most intriguing was, anyway, the information about the previous existence of a “fountain“, as well as of a “coffin-shaped marble vessel“ on the upper part of ruin, as well as of some stone plates, according to the stories of an elder Bulgarian. Since the data of that epoch are scarce, they are worth to be re-evaluated. In this respect, a careful translation was done, with due attention to debatable findings. The pieces, images and symbols associated to the ruin and with stone parts were correlated with the stages of dismantling and decay, in the historical and religious context of the Ottoman period. The author¢s correlations and interpretations are based on factual arguments, bridging the gap between the archaeologist¢s concepts and local population perceptions and public memory in Dobrudja. Thus, a valuable historical information is recovered, and it was established that the three items of Wutzer report existed and were excavated by Tocilescu. Although they had other initial functions, they correspond to specific components of the hexagonal tower, some of them exposed in museum, other lost in time.
Keywords
DOI: 10.14795/j.v8i1.605
References
ALI-GAZI PASA
Geamia Ali–Gazi Pasa, https://www.destimap.com/index.php?act=attraction&a=Geamia-Ali_Gazi-Pasa%2C-Babadag%2C-Romania (accessed December 2020)
ARHIVELE NATIONALE
http://arhivelenationale.ro/site/download/inventare/Florescu-Bobu-Florea.-1938-1970.-Inv.-1696.pdf (accessed December 2020)
FATMA SULTAN
Turkish Archaeological News, Fatma Sultan Cemetery Edirne, https://turkisharchaeonews.net/object/fatma-sultan-cemetery-edirne (accessed December 2020)
FLORESCU 1959
Florescu, F. B., Monumentul de la Adamklissi, Tropaeum Traiani (Editura Academiei Republicii Populare Romîne, București, 1959), 609 p.
FLORESCU 1961
Florescu, F. B., Monumentul de la Adamklissi, Tropaeum Traiani (Ed. a 2-a revăzută și adăugită. Editura Academiei Republicii Populare Romîne, București, 1961), 750 p.
FLORESCU 1965
Florescu, F. B., Das Siegesdenkmal von Adamklissi, Tropaeum Traiani (Verlag Der Akademie Der Rumanischen Volksrepublik, Bukarest, Rudolf Habelt Verlag, Bonn, 1965), 738 p.
FLORESCU 1960
Florescu, R., Noi puncte de vedere şi noi propuneri cu privire la reconstituirea monumentului de la Adamclisi. „Monumente istorice, studii şi lucrări de restaurare", 1960
FLORESCU 1976
Florescu, R., Consideraţii asupra monumentului triumfal de la Adamclisi. Revista muzeelor și monumentelor. Monumente istorice și de artă, nr. 1, 1976, Anul XLV
FOUNTAIN
https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fountain (accessed December 2020)
FURTWÄNGLER 1903
Furtwängler. A., Das Tropaion von Adamklissi und provinzialrömische Kunst (Mit 12 Tafeln und mehreren Textbildern). Aus den Abhandlungen der k. bayer. Akademie der Wiss. I. Gl. XXII. Bd. III. Abth. Verlag der k. Akademie in Commission des G. Franz'schen Verlags (J. Roth). München 1903. 76 p
GEORGESCU 2014
Georgescu, E. S., Seismic response of Tropaeum Traiani monument, Romania, between history and earthquake engineering assessments. DOI: 10.13140/2.1.3271.9041. Proc. Second European Conference on Earthquake Engineering and Seismology (2ECEES), Istanbul, Turkey, 2014.
GEORGESCU 2015
Georgescu, E. S., Seismic response of Tropaeum Traiani monument, Romania, between history and earthquake engineering assessments. CONSTRUCŢII – No. 1 / 2015.
MADAIN PROJECT
Madain Project, https://madainproject.com/mausoleum_of_sultan_suleyman_the_magnificent (accessed 10.10.2020)
MICLEA/FLORESCU 1980
Miclea, I., Florescu, R., Strămoșii românilor. Vestigii milenare de cultură și artă. Decebal și Traian (Editura Meridiane, 1980. 95 p.
NIEMANN 1898
Niemann, G., Zur Basis des Tropaeums von Adamklissi, Jahreshefte des Österreichischen Archäologischen Institutes in Wien — 1.1898., 138-142, https://digi.ub.uni-heidelberg.de/diglit/oejh1898/0150
PETERS 1867
Peters, K. F., Grundlinien zur Geographie und Geologie der Dobrudscha. ‐ Denkschr. Akad.Wiss. Mathem.‐Naturwiss. Cl., 27/2, 83‐207, 1867, Wien.
SÂMPETRU 1984
Sâmpetru, M., Tropaeum Traiani II. Roman monuments (Editura Academiei Republicii Socialiste România, București, 1984), 197 p.
TOCILESCU/BENNDORF/NIEMANN/A 1895
Tocilescu, G./Benndorf, O./Niemann, G., Monumentul de la Adamklissi, Tropaeum Traiani (Wien, A. Hoelder, 1895), Romanian Edition, 182 p.
TOCILESCU/BENNDORF/NIEMANN/B 1895
Tocilescu, G./Benndorf, O./Niemann, G., Das Monument von Adamklissi – Tropaeum Traiani (Wien, A. Hoelder, 1895), German Edition, 172 p.
WIKIPEDIA A 2020
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fontäne (accessed December 2020)
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brunnen (accessed December 2020)
WIKIPEDIA C 2020
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gonbad accessed (accessed December 2020)
WIKIPEDIA D 2020
https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Wilhelm_Wutzer (accessed December 2020)
WUTZER 1860
Wutzer, C. W., Reise in den Orient Europas und einen Theil Westasiens zur Untersuchung des Bodens und seiner Producte, des Klimas der Salubritäts-Verhältnisse und vorherrschenden Krankheiten. Mit Beiträgen zur Geschichte, Charakteristik und Politik der Bewohner. Bd. I, 336 p., (Bädeker, Elberfeld 1860)
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
ISSN: 2360-266X