RUSSIAN AND SOVIET RECEPTION OF CICERO’S VIEWS ON THE IDEAL CITIZEN, RULER, AND STATE IN THE 19-21st centuries
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14795/j.v8i4.683Keywords:
Cicero, antiquity, Ancient Rome, reception, RussianAbstract
The articles deals with the analysis of Russian and Soviet works related to Cicero’s views on the ideal citizen, ruler, and state. There are several contradictory trends in the Russian and Soviet historiography on the topic mentioned above. The first one is about Cicero’s conservatism in ethical and political questions (Grabar’-Passek and Utchenko considered Cicero conservative). A bigger number of scholars, on the contrary, wrote about Cicero’s definite innovation (Derevnin, Kamalutdinov, Temnov, and Bragova). The approach to the essence of Cicero’s concept of the best ruler is also twofold: Vipper and Marchenko attach a monarchical essence to it, while the majority of the scholars (Vekhov, Protasova, Mashkin, Utchenko, Zimin, Motus, Derevnin, Kamalutdinov, Temnov, and Bragova) point to its non-monarchical nature. Zvirevich and Derzhavitsky wrote about the humanism of Cicero’s image of the ideal citizen. Some researchers (Zelinsky, Knabe, Motus, Chernyshov, and Bragova) believe that Cicero’s perfect state was a utopia in the time of transition from the republic to the principate, while Temnov is convinced of its realism.Downloads
References
BRAGOVA 2005
Bragova, A. M., Mark Tullij Ciceron ob ideal'nom grazhdanine i gosudarstve (dissertaciya na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kandidata istoricheskih nauk) (Nizhnij Novgorod).
BRAGOVA 2010
Bragova, A. M., Ciceron o zakonah ideal'nogo gosudarstva, Schole 4 (1), https://nsu.ru/classics/schole/4/schole-4-1.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2011
Bragova, A. M., Interpretaciya Ciceronom stoicheskih ponyatij honestum, virtus, officium, Schole 5 (1), 42-52, https://nsu.ru/classics/schole/5/schole-5-1.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2016a
Bragova, A. M., Ciceronovskij obraz pravitelya, Studia humanitatis 4, http://st-hum.ru/content/bragova-am-ciceronovskiy-obraz-pravitelya. Accessed 18 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2016b
Bragova, A. M., Ponyatie «gosudarstvo» v sochineniyah Cicerona, Samarskij nauchnyj vestnik 1 (14), 93-97 http://biosamara.ru/const/snv/numbers/snv14.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2016c
Bragova, A., The Concept Cum Dignitate Otium in Cicero’s Writings, Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica 22 (1), 45-49,http://saa.uaic.ro/the-concept-cum-dignitate-otium-in-ciceros-writings/. Accessed 10 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2016d
Bragova, A. M., The Concept Amicitia in Cicero’s Writings, Problemy istorii, filologii, kul'tury 1 (51), 103-110, http://pifk.magtu.ru/doc/2016/1/all.pdf. Accessed 18 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2018
Bragova, A., Cicero on Vices, Studia Antiqua et Archaeologica 24 (2), 253-277, http://saa.uaic.ro/cicero-on-vices/. Accessed 18 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2019
Bragova, A. M., Ponyatie ambitio v trudah Cicerona, Uchenye zapiski Novgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta 4 (22), https://www.novsu.ru/univer/press/eNotes1/i.1086055/?id=1544020. Accessed 18 November 2021.
BRAGOVA 2020
Bragova, A., Analysis of Cicero’s Concept of cognitio, Journal of Ancient History and Archaeology 7 (3), 5-11.
CHEKANOVA 2001
Chekanova, N. V. Transformaciya predstavlenij o publichnoj vlasti i ee nositelyah v Rime v epohu grazhdanskih vojn. In: Antichnoe obshchestvo-4: Vlast' i obshchestvo v antichnosti (materialy nauchnoj konferencii 5-7 marta 2001 g.) (Sankt-Peterburg), 129-136.
CHERNYSHOV 1992
Chernyshov, Yu. G. Byla li u rimlyan utopiya?, Vestnik drevnej istorii 1, 53-72.
DEMINA 2000
Demina, S. S., Rimskoe obshchestvo v I v. do n.e. (grazhdanskoe soznanie i povedenie) (dissertaciya na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kandidata istoricheskih nauk) (Vladimir).
DEMINA 2012
Demina, S. S., Grazhdanskoe soznanie i povedenie rimlyan I v. do n.e. (Vladimir).
DEMINA 2015a
Demina, S. S., Gnev i politiko-pravovaya zhizn' rimskogo obshchestva v predstavleniyah Cicerona, Istoricheskaya psihologiya gosudarstvennogo upravleniya 2, 14-20.
DEMINA 2015b
Demina, S. S., Predstavleniya Cicerona o vojne, Problemy istorii, filologii, kul'tury 4 (50), 33-38.
DEMINA 2016
Demina, S. S., Predstavleniya Cicerona o lyubvi, Schole 10 (2), 521-526.
DERATANI 1959a
Deratani, N. F., K voprosu ob istoricheskoj obuslovlennosti obraza oratora u Cicerona. In: N. F. Deratani (red.), M.T. Ciceron: 2000 let so vremeni smerti (sbornik statej) (Moskva), 55-71.
DERATANI 1959b
Deratani, N. F. (red.), M. T. Ciceron: 2000 let so vremeni smerti (sbornik statej) (Moskva).
DEREVNIN 1985
Derevnin, A. A., Uchenie Cicerona o gosudarstve i prave (avtoreferat na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kandidata yuridicheskih nauk) (Moskva).
DERZHAVITSKY 1998
Derzhavickij, E. V., Lichnost' i politika v filosofii Cicerona (dissertaciya na soisk. uch. st. kand. filos. nauk) (Sankt-Peterburg).
FEDOROV 2012
Fedorov, D. A., Social'naya priroda cheloveka v uchenii Cicerona, Vestnik INZHEKONa, seriya: Gumanitarnye nauki 4, 360-362.
FEDOROV 2015
Fedorov, D. A., Social'no-kommunikativnaya problematika v sochineniyah Marka Tulliya Cicerona (Sankt-Peterburg).
FEDOROV 2016a
Fedorov, D. A., O nekotoryh ponyatiyah v social'noj filosofii Cicerona, Nauchnoe mnenie 6-7, 43-46.
FEDOROV 2016b
Fedorov, D. A., Idejnye predposylki social'noj filosofii Cicerona, Vestnik hristianskoj gumanitarnoj akademii 17 (3), 54-61.
FEDOROV 2016c
Fedorov, D. A., Social'no-filosofskie vozzreniya Marka Tulliya Cicerona (dissertaciya na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni doktora filosofskih nauk) (Sankt-Peterburg).
GORENSTEIN 1975
Gorenstein, V. O., Ciceron v gody grazhdanskoj vojny 49-45 gg. i diktatury Cezarya. Dialogi «O starosti» i «O druzhbe». In: Mark Tullij Ciceron. O starosti. O druzhbe. Ob obyazannostyah (Moskva), 175-191.
GRABAR’-PASSEK 1993
Grabar'-Passek, M. E., M. T. Ciceron (stat'ya vpervye opublikovana v 1962 g.). In: Gorenstein V. O. (red.), M. T. Ciceron. Rechi, tom 1 (Moskva), 365-385.
KAMALUTDINOV 1986a
Kamalutdinov, Ya. K., Ciceron i rimskaya diktatura I v. do n.e. In: Antichnaya grazhdanskaya obshchina (Moskva), 68-79.
KAMALUTDINOV 1986b
Kamalutdinov, Ya. K., Ciceron o roli i meste princeps v politicheskoj teorii rimskogo obshchestva (po materialam traktata «O gosudarstve»). In: Antichnyj mir i arheologiya (Saratov), 19-29.
KAMALUTDINOV 1990
Kamalutdinov, Ya. K., K harakteristike politiko-pravovyh vzglyadov Cicerona. In: Iz istorii social'no-eticheskih i politiko-pravovyh idej (Saratov), 53-71.
KARASEVA 2003
Karaseva, A. V., Obraz zhizni i intellektual'naya deyatel'nost' rimskoj intelligencii v I veke do n.e. (preimushchestvenno po okruzheniyu Cicerona) (avtoreferat na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kandidata istoricheskih nauk) (Moskva).
KNABE 1991
Knabe, G. S., Problema Cicerona. In: Grimal'. Ciceron (Moskva, 1991), 5-20.
KOVALEV 1949
Kovalev, S. I., M.T. Ciceron. In: M. T. Ciceron. Pis'ma, Gorenstein, V. O. (perevod), tom 1 (Moskva-Leningrad, 1949), 387-402.
KOZLOVTSEVA/PICHUGINA 2016
Kozlovtseva, E. A., Pichugina, V. K., Ekofilosofiya obrazovaniya Marka Tulliya Cicerona. In: Evolyuciya pedagogicheskoj teorii i praktiki v istorii chelovecheskogo obshchestva (Moskva), 77-83.
LAZAREVA/PICHUGINA 2017
Lazareva, N. N., Pichugina V. K., Obrazovatel'nyj ideal vospitaniya kul'turoj v trudah Cicerona: diskursivnye i kul'turnye dominanty. In: Evolyuciya obrazovaniya i razvitie pedagogicheskoj mysli v istorii
civilizacii (Moskva), 63-70.
LIVSHITS 1955
Livshits, G. M., Obshchestvenno-politicheskie vzglyady Cicerona, Belorusskij gosudarstvennyj universitet. Uchenye zapiski 23 (Minsk), 124-139.
MARCHENKO 1974
Marchenko, G. M., Antichnaya tradiciya o principes civitatis, Vestnik Leningradskogo universiteta 3 (14), 56-62.
MARCHENKO 1976
Marchenko, G. M., Ciceron o edinolichnom pravlenii (po materialam traktata «O gosudarstve»), Vestnik Leningradskogo universiteta 2 (8), 143-147.
MARCHENKO 1980
Marchenko, G. M., Princeps civitatis v politicheskih vzglyadah Cicerona (avtoreferat dissertacii na soiskanie uchenoj stepeni kandidata istoricheskih nauk) (Leningrad).
MASHKIN 1949
Mashkin, N. A., Principat Avgusta (Moskva-Leningrad).
MOTUS 1983
Motus, A. A., Ciceron i Sallyustij v ih otnoshenii k grazhdanskim vojnam Drevnego Rima (I v. do n.e.), Antichnyj mir i arheologiya 5 (Saratov), 33-45.
PAVLOV 2001
Pavlov, A. A., K voprosu o libertas u Cicerona. In: Zhebelevskie chteniya-4 (tezisy dokladov nauchnoj konferencii 30 oktyabrya – 1 noyabrya 2001 g.) (Sankt-Peterburg).URL: http://centant.pu.ru/centrum/publik/confcent/2002-10/pavlov.htm. Accessed 10 November 2021.
PETROVSKY 1958
Petrovskij, F. A. (red.), M.T. Ciceron (sbornik statej) (Moskva).
PICHUGINA 2013
Pichugina, V. K., Antropologicheskij diskurs «zaboty o sebe» Marka Tulliya Cicerona, Istoriko-pedagogicheskij zhurnal 2, 158-168.
PICHUGINA/SHIRINSKAYA 2015
Pichugina, V. K., Shirinskaya, K. V., Drevnegrecheskij ideal obrazovannogo cheloveka v korpuse sochinenij Cicerona, Nauchnyj dialog 4 (40), 124-136.
PICHUGINA/LAZAREVA 2016
Pichugina, V. K., Lazareva, N. N., Teoretiko-metodologicheskie osnovy istoriko-pedagogicheskogo izucheniya traktata Cicerona «Ob obyazannostyah». In: Metodologicheskie resursy kachestva
pedagogicheskih issledovanij (materialy mezhdunarodnoj setevoj nauchnoj konferencii RAO «Metodologiya nauchnogo issledovaniya v pedagogike»), 56-61.
PICHUGINA 2016a
Pichugina, V. K., Voprosy vospitaniya poeziej i teatral'nymi zrelishchami v sochineniyah Cicerona. In: Teoriya i praktika obrazovaniya: istoriya i sovremennost' (Moskva),53-63.
PICHUGINA 2016b
Pichugina, V. K., Istoriko-pedagogicheskoe izuchenie naslediya Cicerona: vozmozhnosti diskursivnoj metodologii. In: Metodologiya nauchnogo issledovaniya v pedagogike (Moskva),175-182.
PICHUGINA/VOROBYEVA 2017
Pichugina, V. K., Vorobyeva, K. V., (Samo)vospitanie poeziej i teatrom v sochineniyah Cicerona, Hypothekai. Zhurnal po istorii antichnoj pedagogicheskoj kul'tury 1, 59-76.
PICHUGINA 2017
Pichugina, V. K., Pedagogicheskaya koncepciya voenno-politicheskogo liderstva: ot Ksenofonta k Ciceronu, Istoriko-pedagogicheskij zhurnal 2, 196-204.
PICHUGINA 2018
Pichugina, V., Paideia and Humanitas in Cicero’s Instruction, Kwartalnik Pedagogoczny 63
(1 (247)), 198-205.
POKROVSKY 1913
Pokrovsky, M. M., Tolkovanie traktata Cicerona «De re publica» (Moskva).
PROTASOVA 1927
Protasova, S. I., Traktat Cicerona «O gosudarstve», Uchenye zapiski Saratovskogo Gosudarstvennogo Universiteta 6 (Saratov), 267-277.
RADZIG 1959
Radzig, S. I., Ciceron i ego vremya. In: Deratani, N. F. (red.), M. T. Ciceron: 2000 let so vremeni smerti (sbornik statej) (Moskva), 9-54.
SERGEEV 1938
Sergeev, V. S., Ocherki po istorii drevnego Rima, chast' 1 (Москва).
TEMNOV 1999
Temnov, E. I., Ciceron – orator, politik, pravoved. In: Temnov E. I. (red.), M.T. Ciceron. O gosudarstve. O zakonah. O starosti. O druzhbe. Ob obyazannostyah. Rechi. Pis'ma (Moskva), 5-40.
TRONSKY 1949
Tronsky, I. M., Postroenie traktata Cicerona «O gosudarstve» i ego politicheskie tendencii, Doklady i soobshcheniya filologicheskogo instituta Leningradskogo gos. Universiteta 1 (Leningrad), 180-185.
UTCHENKO 1966
Utchenko, S. L., Politiko-filosofskie traktaty Cicerona. In: Utchenko, S. L. (red.), M.T. Ciceron. Dialogi. O gosudarstve. O zakonah (Moskva), 153-174.
UTCHENKO 1972
Utchenko, S. L., Ciceron i ego vremya (Москва).
UTCHENKO 1975
Utchenko, S. L., Traktat Cicerona «Ob obyazannostyah» i obraz ideal'nogo grazhdanina. In: Utchenko, S. L. (ред.), M.T. Ciceron. O starosti. O druzhbe. Ob obyazannostyah (Moskva),159-174.
UTCHENKO 1977
Utchenko, S. L., Politicheskie ucheniya Drevnego Rima (Moskva).
VEKHOV 1882
Vekhov, S. I., Sochinenie Cicerona «O gosudarstve» (Sankt-Peterburg).
VIPPER 1995a
Vipper, R, Yu., Ocherki po istorii Rimskoj imperii, tom 1 (Rostov-na-Donu) (reprint).
VIPPER 1995b
Vipper, R, Yu., Ocherki po istorii Rimskoj imperii, tom 2 (Rostov-na-Donu) (reprint).
ZELINSKY 1901
Zelinsky, Th., Ciceron v istorii evropejskoj kul'tury (proizneseno v yanvare 1895 g.). In: Mark Tullij Ciceron. Polnoj sobranie rechej v russkom perevode (otchasti V.A. Alekseeva, otchasti Th. Zelinskogo), tom 1 (Sankt-Peterburg), XXIII-LVIII.
ZELINSKY 1993
Zelinsky, Th., Ciceron. In: Enciklopedicheskij slovar' F. A. Brokgauza – I. A. Efrona, tom 75 (Moskva), 254-274 (reprint).
ZIMIN 1975
Zimin, V. P., Ciceronovskaya koncepciya nailuchshego gosudarstvennogo ustrojstva, Voprosy otechestvennoj i vseobshchej istorii (Kujbyshev), 186-193.
ZVIREVICH 1988
Zvirevich, V, T., Ciceron – filosof, istorik filosofii (Sverdlovsk).
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal, we use CC BY-NC-ND license (Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs) wich only allowing others to download your works and share them with others as long as they credit you, but they can’t change them in any way or use them commercially.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
