A Gaze from the Fourth Century. Part two: the rendering of Christ in the Temple Icon of the Theotokos
Abstract
In the article published in Byzantinoslavica, vol. 65, 2007 about the so-called ‘Temple icon’ in London, I argue that this piece on cloth in wax encaustic technique (now in a private collection) dates from the fourth century. In doing so I opposed the estimation of it belonging to the sixth-seventh centuries made, among others, by Robin Cormack. Within that piece I brought evidence in connection to Mary. In the current paper I provide information which refers especially to the way the infant Jesus is depicted within the icon in order to back this dating: Christ is shown wearing a tunic with purple clavi, a bulla, and an earring in the manner Roman children display in the portraits that survived from the third-fourth centuries AD. There are depictions of youngsters similar to such a rendering at Antinoopolis (c. AD 250-300) and Fayum (four century).
Additionally, I add a later observation concerning the Virgin: there are communalities between the icon in the UK and the Hodegetria wood panel in the chapel of St. Francisca Romana, which has been certainly attested to the fifth century - nuclear magnetic resonance sensors have been used for such a purpose. The most striking common features are the style in which the face of Mary is depicted and the manner in which the expression of her eyes has been rendered in both icons. Moreover, the shape of Mary’s vestment around the neck and its general appearance are the same in both icons.
The pieces date from the pre-iconoclastic period and were transported from the East in countries pertaining to Western Christendom: the icon in Rome by Angelo Frangipane (in the fifth or sixth century), the other one probably by merchants or Napoleon’s army (to France, from where Richard Temple and Laurence Morocco brought it to the UK).
Keywords
DOI: 10.14795/j.v6i1.380
References
Barker, M., ‘Wisdom Imagery and the Mother of God’, L. Brubaker and M. B. Cunningham (eds.), The Cult of the Mother of God in Byzantium: Texts and Images, Birmingham Byzantine and Ottoman Studies 11 (Aldershot, Hampshire), 2011, 92-108
Borg, B., Mumienporträts. Chronologie und kultureller Kontext (Mainz: P. von Zabern), 1996
Brubaker L. and M.B. Cunningham (eds.), The Cult of the Mother of God in Byzantium: Texts and Images (Farnham and Burlington, V.T.: Ashgate), 2011
Calament, F., La révélation d'Antinoé par Albert Gayet: histoire, archéologie, muséographie (Cairo/Le Caire: Institut français d'archéologie orientale), series Bibliothèque d’études coptes, t. 18/1-2, 2005
Calament, F., R. Eichmann, and C. Vendries, Le luth dans l’Egypte byzantine: la tombe de la “Prophetesse d'Antinoe” au Musee de Grenoble (Musée de Grenoble, Rahden/Westf.: VML, Verlag Marie Leidorf), 2012
Calament, F. and D. Maximilien, Antinoé, à la vie, à la mode: visions d'élégance dans les solitudes, Musées des tissus et des arts décoratifs de Lyon (Musée du Louvre; Opéra de Lyon, Lyon: Fage), 2013
Calament, F., “Les fouilles d’Antinoé d’hier à aujourd’hui: un mise en perspective”, in Y. Lintz and M. Coudert (eds.), Antinoé: momies, textiles, céramiques et autres antiques: envois de l'État et dépôts du musée du Louvre de 1901 à nos jours, Musée du Louvre, Département des antiquités égyptiennes (Paris: Somogy éditions d’art, Louvre éditions), 2013, 23-29
Cantone, V., ‘Iconografia mariana e culto popolare nel codice Siriaco 341 di Parigi’, Rivista di Storia della Miniatura, XV (2011), pp. 17-25
Cellini, P., Falsi e restauri: oltre l’apparenza (Rome: Archivio Guido Izzi), 1992
Coli, M., G. Rosati, G. Pini, and M. Baldi, ‘The Roman quarries at Antinoopolis (Egypt): development and techniques’, Journal of Archaeological Science, 2011, vol. 38 (10), 2696-2707
Collins, K. M and R. S. Nelson, Holy Image, Hallowed Ground: Icons from Sinai, Los Angeles, Calif.: J. Paul Getty Museum, 2007, 3rd printing
Coudert M., S. Mérigeaud, P-L. Thillaud, and L. Dussarps, ‘Momies’, in Y. Lintz, and M. Coudert (eds.), Antinoé: momies, textiles, céramiques et autres antiques: envois de l'État et dépôts du musée du Louvre de 1901 à nos jours, Musée du Louvre, Département des antiquités égyptiennes (Paris: Somogy éditions d’art, Louvre éditions), 2013, 175-255
Cormack, R., ‘Virgin and Child from Egypt’, R. Temple (ed.), Masterpieces of Early Christian Art and Icons, catalogue published by the Temple Gallery based on the exhibition, Icons, 15th June-30th July 2005 (London: Temple Gallery), 2005, 22-29
Doxiadis, E., The mysterious Fayum portraits: faces from ancient Egypt (London: Thames and Hudson), 1995
Ene D-Vasilescu, E., ‘A Gaze from the Fourth Century: The Theotokos Icon of the Temple Gallery’, Byzantinoslavica 65, 2007, 83-90
Grabar, A., The Beginnings of Christian Art. 200-395, Thames and Hudson Edition, 1967
Hoesch, N., ‘Mumienporträts’, in H. Cancik, H. Schneider, and M. Landfester (eds.),
Der Neue Pauly, Munich, vol. 8, 2000
Lintz, Y. and M. Coudert (eds.), Antinoé: momies, textiles, céramiques et autres antiques: envois de l'État et dépôts du musée du Louvre de 1901 à nos jours, Musée du Louvre, Département des antiquités égyptiennes (Paris: Somogy éditions d’art, Louvre éditions), 2013
Mathews, T. F., ‘The Emperor and the Icon’, in Acta ad archaeologiam et artium historiam pertinentia, Inst. Rom. Norvegiae, 15 (2001), 164 -177
Mathews, T. F, ‘Sinai icons’, in K. M. Collins and R. S. Nelson, Holy Image, Hallowed Ground: Icons from Sinai, Los Angeles, Calif.: J. Paul Getty Museum, 2007, 3rd printing
Montserrat, D., Antinoöpolis (Oxford: Oxford University Press), part of Grove Art Online
Nyborg, C., Santa Francesca Romana, Rome (no publisher mentioned), 2000
Parlasca, K., “Ein römisches Leichentuch aus Ägypten in Genf”/”A Roman shroud from Egypt in Geneva”, Chronique d’Egypte, January 2011, vol. 86 (pp. 171-172),?? pp. 298-322
Parlasca, K., Mumienporträts und verwandte Denkmäler, Deutsches Archäologisches Institut, publ. Wiesbaden: Steiner, 1966
Parlasca, K., “Mumienporträts und verwandte Denkmäler”, in A. Adriani (ed.), Repertorio d’arte dell’Egitto, Edizioni private e varie, 1966, 127, note 22, p. 142, N. 16, p. 147, PL. 33, N. 2
Parlasca, K. and Seemann, H. (eds.), Augenblicke. Mumienporträts und ägyptische Grabkunst aus römischer Zeit [zur Ausstellung Augenblicke - Mumienporträts und Ägyptische Grabkunst aus Römischer Zeit, in der Schirn-Kunsthalle Frankfurt (30. Januar bis 11. April 1999)]/ Moments. Mummy portraits and Egyptian burial art from Roman times [for the exhibition moments-mummy portraits and Egyptian grave art from Roman times, in the Schirn-Kunsthalle Frankfurt, Munich, 1999
Parlasca, K., “Ritratti di Mummie”, Repertorio d’arte dell’Egitto II, Edizioni private e varie, (1977)
Parlasca, K., “Ritratti di mummie”, in A. Adriani (ed.), Repertorio d’arte dell’Egitto greco-romano, Serie B, 1-4, Rome, 1969-2003 (Corpus of most of the known mummy portraits), particularly for this article Parlasca, K. and Hans G. Frenz, Ritratti di mummie, in A. Adriani (ed.) Repertorio d'arte dell'Egitto greco-romano, Serie B, IV, Rome: L’Erma di Bretschneider, 2003
Parlasca, K. and H. Seemann (eds.), Augenblicke: Mumienporträts und ägyptische Grabkunst aus römischer Zeit/Moments. Mummy portraits and Egyptian burial art from Roman times, Schirn-Kunsthalle/Art Gallery Frankfurt, exhibition 30 Januar bis 11. April 1999, Munich: Klinkhardt & Biermann, 1999
Petrie, W. M. F (ed.), Roman Portraits and Memphis IV, Memphis, Band 4 (London: British Museum), 1911
Proietti, N., D. Capitani, and V. Di Tullio, ‘Applications of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Sensors to Cultural Heritage’, in Sensors, vol. 14 (2014), pp. 6983-6984
Reekmans, L., Le Complexe Cémétérial du Pape Gaius dans la Catacombe de Callixte, Citta del Vaticano/the Vatican: Pontificio Istituto di archeologia cristiana, 1988
Riggs, C., The beautiful burial in Roman Egypt: art, identity, and funerary religion, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2005
Picton, J., S. Quirke and P. C. Roberts (eds.), Living Images, Egyptian Funerary Portraits in the Petrie Museum (Walnut Creek, CA:: Left Coast Press), 2007; electronic version Routledge 2018
Roberts, P., Mummy portraits from Roman Egypt (London: British Museum Press), 2008
Seipel, W. (ed.), Bilder aus dem Wüstensand. Mumienportraits aus dem Ägyptischen Museum Kairo; eine Ausstellung des Kunsthistorischen Museums Wien, Milan, 20; October 1998 - 24, January 1999 (Wien: Kunsthistorisches Museum; Milano: Skira, Ostfildern),1998
Stamm, R. (ed.), Paula Modersohn-Becker und die ägyptischen Mumienportraits: Eine Hommage zum 100. Geburtstag der Künstlerin. Katalogbuch zur Ausstellung in Bremen, Kunstsammlung Böttcherstraße, exhibitions Paula-Modersohn-Becker-Museum, Bremen, 13 October 2007 - 24 February 2008; Museum Ludwig, Köln, 15 March -15 June 2008] (Munich: Hirme), 2007
Trevisiol, R. with M-CBruwier, and F. Calament, Textiles coptes: Collection Maria Luise et Robert Fill-Trevisiol; Musée royal de Mariemont, host institution (Brussels: Fondation Roi Baudouin), 2015
Vassilaki, M. (ed.), Images of the Mother of God. Perceptions of the Theotokos in Byzantium (Aldershot: Ashgate), 2005
Vinciguerra, A., “I Ritratti di mummia del periodo greco-romano da Antinoupolis”, in Rivista degli studi orientali, Sapienza - Universita di Roma, Nuova Serie, vol. 85, Fasc. 1/4 (2012) (Rome: Universita di Roma), 553-581
Walker, S., Ancient faces: mummy portraits from Roman Egypt, New York, N.Y. Metropolitan Museum of Art: Routledge; British Museum. Department of Egyptian Antiquities, London: Published for the Trustees of the British Museum by British Museum Press, 2000; reprint S. Walker, M. Bierbrier, and C. Johns, Ancient Faces: mummy Portraits from Roman Egypt (London: British Museum), 1997
Walker, S., “Porträts auf leichentüchern aus Antinoopolis. Einige Anmerkungen zu Kleidung und Datierung”, Parlasca, K. and H. Seemann (eds.), Augenblicke: Mumienporträts und ägyptische Grabkunst aus römischer Zeit, Schirn Kunsthalle/Art Gallery Frankfurt (Munich: Klinkhardt & Biermann), 1999, 74-78
Whitehouse, H., ‘Wondrous Curiosities. Ancient Egypt at the British Museum’,
Journal of the History of Collections, Oxford University Press, 2008, vol. 20(1), 143-144
Walker, S., “Mummy Portraits in their Roman Context”, in M. L. Bierbrier (ed.),
Portraits and Masks: Burial Customs in Roman Egypt (London: British Museum), 1997, 1-6
Wrede, H., Mumienporträts, in Lexikon der Ägyptologie, Bd. IV (Wiesbaden: Harrassowitz), 1982, column 218-222.
Refbacks
- There are currently no refbacks.
ISSN: 2360-266X